Research by: Daniel Broby
Executive Summary
The manuscript demonstrates how a classroom assignment developed specifically for the Asian Institute of Management’s MSc Financial Technology programme can contribute to the academic literature on experiential learning, organisational behaviour, and financial management education.
The research originated from a practical teaching exercise designed to help students understand the strategic challenges facing incumbent banks and emerging financial technology companies. Rather than relying exclusively on conventional lectures, case studies, or financial modelling exercises, the assignment places students in simulated management positions. Working in competing teams, participants assume responsibility for either an established bank or a fintech challenger.
Their objective is to make strategic decisions concerning lending rates, credit risk, technology investment, and customer acquisition while maintaining financial viability. The lecturer assumes the role of financial regulator, introducing changes in capital requirements and unexpected economic shocks. The simulation proceeds through successive decision rounds, with each team’s choices influencing subsequent profitability, market share, equity, and capital adequacy. Consequently, students experience how decisions that appear commercially attractive in the short term can create financial constraints that restrict future strategic options.
The paper connects financial decision-making with established theories of organisational behaviour, particularly bounded rationality, escalation of commitment, strategic myopia, and organisational adaptation.
A central contribution is the treatment of regulatory capital as a constraint that evolves in response to managerial decisions. This allows students to observe how financial performance, institutional requirements, and competitive pressure jointly influence organisational conduct.
The research also investigates the simulation’s computational properties through Monte Carlo analysis. Across 100 simulated scenarios, each comprising ten decision rounds, the model generates materially different financial outcomes for incumbent banks and fintech challengers.
The results demonstrate that fintech entrants can exhibit greater financial variability because of their smaller initial capital bases and exposure to funding and credit shocks. In one sensitivity experiment, increasing the minimum capital requirement from 8% to 12% reduces the simulated fintech insolvency frequency from 4% to 1%. These findings illustrate the trade-off between financial expansion and institutional resilience within the simulation. They are not presented as empirical estimates of actual banking-sector insolvency risk.
The publication is particularly relevant to AIM’s emphasis on applied management education. The original classroom assignment has been developed into a structured teaching instrument supported by Excel and Python implementations, assessment guidance, and an instructor teaching note. Its principal educational contribution is to connect financial theory with managerial judgement through repeated decisions and observable consequences.
The simulation can also be adapted for MBA programmes, executive education, and other courses examining decision-making under uncertainty. Although developed for financial services, its underlying principles have potential applications in other regulated sectors, including insurance, healthcare, energy, and public infrastructure.
To cite this article:
Broby, D. (2026). Simulating strategic decision making under capital constraint: Bank and fintech competition under shocks. Journal of Organizational Behavior Education, 19.
To access the article:
https://www.neilsonjournals.com/JOBE/abstractjobe19broby.html
About the journal
| JOURNAL OF ORGANIZATIONAL BEHAVIOR EDUCATION About: The Journal of Organizational Behavior Education (JOBE) aims to enhance organizational behavior education worldwide through the publication of high-quality refereed organizational behavior teaching materials. The goal is to attract contributions from individuals within the profession who excel in the creation and teaching of organizational behavior and business communication lectures and who have developed exceptional teaching materials and new approaches in the field. | |
| Publisher | NeilsonJournals Publishing |
| Review System | Peer-reviewed |
| Financial Times 50 | Not Ranked |
| Chartered Association of Business Schools Academic Journal Guide 2024 | ABS 1 |
| Scimago Journal & Country Rank, 2025 | h-index: 2 | SJR: 0.153 |
| Scopus, 2025 | CiteScore: 0.2 |
| Australian Business Deans Council Journal List, 2025 | Rating C |
| Journal Citation Reports (Clarivate), 2025 | Not Ranked |